Energies Media
  • Magazine
    • Digital Magazine
    • Digital Magazine Archive
  • Features
  • Upstream
  • Midstream
  • Downstream
  • Renewable
    • Solar
    • Wind
    • Hydrogen
    • Nuclear
  • People
  • Events
  • Advertise
No Result
View All Result
Energies Media
No Result
View All Result

Landmark Supreme Court Ruling Could Threaten Future UK Oil Drilling

by Energies Media Staff
June 20, 2024
in Exploration & Production, News, Oil and Gas News, Scoop.it
d787ed53 2260 498a 9e1d c6a431df3914

Texas Consultancy Develops AI to Address Project Challenges in the U.S. Energy Sector

A Critical Mineral at a Critical Moment: The Importance of Restoring Domestic Tungsten Production in the U.S.

The Supreme Court has ruled a local council should have considered the full climate impact of burning oil from new wells – a landmark decision which could put future UK oil and gas projects in question.

Under planning law the assumption has always been that only the impacts from constructing the wells and not the use of the final oil products should be considered.

The case brought against Surrey County Council by Sarah Finch, on behalf of campaigners could threaten new UK fossil fuels projects.

The council said it believed at the time it had followed planning law.

The Supreme Court judges did not rule that Surrey County Council should reject the proposal for new oil wells but that it should have considered the downstream emissions.

While this precedent for taking emissions from products like oil into account does not stop new drilling it is something companies will have to consider when looking at new projects.

“I am absolutely over the moon to have won this important case,” Sarah Finch told supporters.

Today’s judgement relates to the Horse Hill oil well in Surrey. The site was given planning permission to expand its operations in 2019, a decision that was challenged by Ms Finch, on behalf of Weald Action Group.

Lawyers acting for Ms Finch said that as part of the Environmental Impact Assessment the council should have considered not just the greenhouse gas emissions from building the wells but also burning any oil that was then used – known as downstream emissions.

In a three-to-two majority the Supreme Court judges agreed.

Summing up the case Lord Leggatt said it was “inevitable” that oil from the site will be burned, and the resulting greenhouse emissions were “straightforwardly results of the project” which should be considered.

The six wells at Horse Hill are expected to produce 3.3 million tonnes of crude oil over the next 20 years. Burning that oil would produce over 10 million tonnes of CO2, the environmental campaigning organisation Friends of the Earth has estimated.

Stephen Sanderson, the chief executive of UK oil and gas plc – the company behind the Horse Hill project said the court’s ruling was “perplexing”.

But he added “the company’s focus over the past few years has shifted away from oil and gas and firmly towards … hydrogen storage.”

UK oil and gas plc said they will now work with Surrey County Council to amend its planning application, and that future production will fall below the levels at which an environmental assessment is required.

Campaigners claim the judgement could also affect ongoing legal challenges of new projects in the UK including Rosebank oil field and the proposed coal mine in Whitehaven in Cumbria.

“Today’s groundbreaking ruling is a heavy blow for fossil fuel lobbyists,” said Weald Action Group.

“The UK is already veering dangerously off track for meeting its legally binding carbon reduction targets, and its international pledge to reduce emissions by two-thirds by 2030,” they added.

Because the UK law on environmental assessments is based in part on European law the ruling could have impacts abroad as well, they say.

Ms Finch’s victory ends a five-year legal battle on behalf of local residents, in which she was supported by environmental campaigners Friends of the Earth and Greenpeace.

Her challenge to the project was initially rejected in the High Court but when it went to the Appeal Court in 2021 the judges returned a split decision and Ms Finch then took her case to the Supreme Court last year.

The Supreme Court judges did not rule that Surrey County Council should reject the proposal for new oil wells but should have considered the downstream emissions.

Source: energycentral.com

Author Profile
Energies Media Staff
Website
Author Articles
  • Energies Media Staff
    https://energiesmedia.com/author/oilmanwp/
    Drones
    September 8, 2025
    Revolutionizing Renewable Energy with Advanced Drone Technology
  • Energies Media Staff
    https://energiesmedia.com/author/oilmanwp/
    Global Shale Oil and Gas Landscape Set for Growth Beyond US
    August 26, 2025
    Global Shale Oil and Gas Landscape Set for Growth Beyond US
  • Energies Media Staff
    https://energiesmedia.com/author/oilmanwp/
    E-Fuels
    August 13, 2025
    2nd Annual World E-Fuels Summit
  • Energies Media Staff
    https://energiesmedia.com/author/oilmanwp/
    What Happens to Solar and Wind Systems During Natural Disasters?
    August 6, 2025
    What Happens to Solar and Wind Systems During Natural Disasters?
  • Energies Media Staff
    https://energiesmedia.com/author/oilmanwp/
    ship on body of water at night
    August 1, 2025
    Industry leaders to speak at Wood Mackenzie’s Carbon Capture, Utilization and Storage Conference 2025
  • Energies Media Staff
    https://energiesmedia.com/author/oilmanwp/
    ROGII and NRGX Technologies Ltd. Partner to Deliver Seamless LAS Data Integration for Upstream Workflows
    July 31, 2025
    ROGII and NRGX Technologies Ltd. Partner to Deliver Seamless LAS Data Integration for Upstream Workflows
Qatar
InventU

In This Issue

Energies Media Summer 2025

ENERGIES Media (Summer 2025)


Letter from the Managing Editor (Summer 2025)


How to Deploy Next-Gen Energy Savers Without Disrupting Operations


ENERGIES Cartoon (Summer 2025)


U.S. Oil Refineries Face Critical Capacity Test Amid Rising Demand


Why Energy Companies Need a CX Revolution


NeverNude Coveralls: A Practical Solution for Everyday Dignity


Moving Energy Across Space and Time


Dewey Follett Bartlett, Jr.: Tulsa’s Champion of Independents


Maximizing Clean Energy Tax Credits Under the Inflation Reduction Act


Meeting Emergency Preparedness and Response Criteria


Energies Media Interactive Crossword Puzzle – Summer 2025


The Hidden Value in Waste Oil: A Sustainable Solution for the Future


Bringing Safety Forward in Offshore Operations

E-Fuels
TAMU
  • Terms
  • Privacy

© 2025 by Energies Media

No Result
View All Result
  • Magazine
    • Digital Magazine
    • Digital Magazine Archive
  • Features
  • Upstream
  • Midstream
  • Downstream
  • Renewable
    • Solar
    • Wind
    • Hydrogen
    • Nuclear
  • People
  • Events
  • Advertise

© 2025 by Energies Media