Wind turbines sway like “tuning forks” before their blades are fitted and engineers finally have a way to see it coming
A wind turbine tower standing alone on a construction site — rotor not yet attached, nacelle not yet in place — looks solid enough to ignore the wind. It isn’t. At moderate speeds, airflow curling off the cylindrical steel structure can shed vortices in a rhythmic pattern, locking onto the tower’s natural frequency and driving it into sustained, crosswise oscillations. Engineers may now have a path forward.
When stillness becomes dangerous
The mechanism behind VIV is deceptively simple. Wind flowing around a cylindrical tower sheds vortices alternately from each side — a process called vortex shedding. When that shedding frequency aligns with the tower’s natural bending frequency, the two systems lock together. The result is sustained, large-amplitude crosswind oscillations the structure can’t easily escape.
A bare tower awaiting its rotor-nacelle assembly is especially vulnerable. Removing that mass shifts the natural frequency, changing which wind speeds trigger lock-in. Extra-tall towers built for low-wind sites face additional exposure — greater height can push vortex shedding toward the tower’s second bending mode, typically at 15–20 m/s. Crosswind oscillations are most dangerous because aerodynamic damping there is low, which accelerates fatigue damage and, in worst cases, threatens structural integrity.
Researchers from the National Technical University of Athens recalibrated this model using wind tunnel data from two independent experiments: Belloli et al.
Why existing models fall short
Engineers have two main tool classes for predicting VIV. The first adds nonlinear aeroelastic force terms into a single equation of motion. Models in this category — including those proposed by Scanlan — can identify peak vibration amplitude during lock-in but struggle to trace how amplitude evolves across the full lock-in range without continuous re-calibration.
The second class uses two coupled equations: one governing structural motion, one governing the evolving lift force. These lift-oscillator models can reproduce the complete amplitude profile across the lock-in region with constant parameter values. Neither class, though, performs well enough for routine design use. The Eurocode standard tends to overpredict VIV response, while the Blevins model tends to underpredict amplitudes for real cantilever structures. Neither integrates cleanly into the aeroelastic simulation tools manufacturers rely on for fatigue and structural load assessment.
A two-equation model, freshly calibrated
The Hartlen–Currie model, first proposed in 1970, is a lift-oscillator formulation built on that two-equation structure. One equation describes tower motion; a second describes how the aerodynamic lift coefficient evolves over time. Structural motion feeds back into the lift, and vice versa.
Researchers from the National Technical University of Athens recalibrated this model using wind tunnel data from two independent experiments: Belloli et al. (2012), conducted at the POLIMI wind tunnel, and the classic Feng (1968) dataset from the University of British Columbia. Both involved rigid cylinders on elastic supports, tested across a range of Scruton numbers — the dimensionless parameter combining mass and damping that governs VIV resistance.
The key innovation was allowing the model’s two defining constants to vary linearly across the lock-in velocity range rather than holding them fixed. Casting the equations in non-dimensional form means calibration only needs to happen once for a given set of dimensionless parameters — a practical advantage when applying the model to different tower geometries and site conditions.
From wind tunnel to real tower: the validation test
Calibration on rigid cylinders is only half the problem. Real towers are flexible cantilevers — a fundamentally different structural configuration. The research team embedded the calibrated Hartlen–Currie model into hGAST, NTUA’s in-house multibody aeroelastic solver, and applied it to a flexible cantilevered cylinder modeled as a Timoshenko beam.
Validation used wind tunnel measurements from Lupi et al. (2021). For two higher Scruton number cases — Sc = 5.18 and Sc = 7.02 — the model accurately reproduced observed tip displacement. At the lowest Scruton number tested (Sc ≈ 2.94), the model overpredicted displacement by approximately 55%. The authors attribute this to calibration data: rigid-cylinder experiments show a narrower lock-in region than cantilever structures exhibit, and direct VIV measurements on cantilever cylinders would resolve the discrepancy.
What this means for wind turbine design
The practical value lies in where the model sits. Unlike standalone analytical formulas, the Hartlen–Currie implementation is designed to slot directly into comprehensive aeroelastic design frameworks — letting manufacturers use it alongside existing tools for rotor aerodynamics, structural loads, and fatigue analysis.
Several research directions remain open. Higher-order bending modes, relevant for the tallest towers at low-wind sites, aren’t yet addressed. Ambient turbulence effects on lock-in development are similarly unresolved. Because the formulation is non-dimensional, updating the model when high-Reynolds-number VIV data eventually become available is straightforward.
Wind turbine towers are getting taller, installation campaigns are lasting longer, and the windows during which towers stand unequipped are extending. A reliable, design-integrated VIV prediction tool isn’t just an academic refinement — it’s a practical requirement for building bigger turbines safely and economically.
Reference: Vlastos, D., Tzimi, N., Trampa, G., Riziotis, V., Manolas, D., and Spyropoulos, N.: Calibration and validation of an engineering model for vortex-induced vibration prediction in wind turbine towers, Wind Energ. Sci., 11, 2585–2600, https://doi.org/10.5194/wes-11-2585-2026, 2026.
Daniel García is an Editor-in-Chief with strong expertise in structural work and engineering principles. He combines this technical foundation with deep knowledge of energy, spatial design, and emerging technologies, bringing a forward-thinking and analytical approach to editorial leadership.