Scientists find ice on just the outermost 5% of wind turbine blades can sharply reduce performance
Wind turbines need more than just strong winds to generate electricity. Another issue that can silently sabotage their performance is the freezing temperatures and moisture in the Swiss Alps.
Researchers working on wind energy near Andermatt discovered something especially interesting about the formation of ice. A relatively small frozen piece of a turbine blade can have a large effect on how efficiently it generates electricity.
But what is so important about the very tip of a rotating blade?
The investigation and results are described in a research project of the Swiss Federal Office of Energy and provide a different way to protect wind turbines.
Wind energy challenge in the Swiss Alps
The Alpine Test Site Gütsch, situated around 2,330 meters above sea level, near Andermatt, is researching real icing conditions and comparing them with controlled experiments.
The mountains surrounding Andermatt are perfect for the use of wind energy. Strong winds attract renewable energy projects to higher ground.
But these very settings can produce difficult operating conditions.
In winter, moisture in the air can freeze on exposed surfaces. Wind turbine blades are particularly susceptible, especially when you have a combination of clouds, low temperatures, and strong winds.
The blades are designed to capture energy from moving air, but ice deforms them.
The extra weight from the frozen water and the way ice alters the aerodynamics of the blade; therefore, researchers wanted to find out exactly where ice caused the most trouble.
Why a little ice can cause a much bigger problem
The research entailed understanding the effects of frozen blades. Scientists used a combination of field measurements, laboratory experiments and computer simulations.
They monitored the wind conditions and the turbine performance measurements at Gütsch for a year.The results showed that icing was only part of the problem.
The steep, mountainous terrain alone could reduce the expected annual energy production by up to 23%.
At the conditions recorded at Gütsch, an additional estimated loss of annual energy production of 2% was caused by ice formation. Researchers also looked at different shapes of ice to try to understand if some were more damaging to turbines than others.
They tested these on a smaller model turbine at ETH Zurich, so that they could compare the performance in controlled conditions. The experiments showed large differences.
The ice formations, typical for Gütsch conditions, caused rather moderate energy losses per year. But extreme ice shapes associated with low altitude sites could produce losses up to 17%.
That’s a big difference, as not all frozen turbines will encounter the same challenges. The shape, location, and spread of the ice all influence how much electricity a turbine can generate.
Why the tip of the blade matters
The Swiss Federal Office of Energy research project is particularly important. Researchers have discovered that the ice that forms on the outer 5 percent of a wind turbine’s blades is critical to its performance. A small amount of ice can affect the aerodynamics that help to drive the turbine, and the blades are designed to use airflow in a controlled way to keep them spinning efficiently.
Ice changes the profile of the blade and can cause airflow to separate from the blade’s surface. This reduces aerodynamic efficiency and can have a big effect on power production.
The researchers discovered that the extreme ice formation could result in flow separation over the entire blade span, leading to major production losses.
What they found suggests it may be better to protect the blade tips, rather than treating all sections equally.
With this information, manufacturers can place the protection where it is needed most.
Impact of future innovations
The investigation and results are described in a research project of the Swiss Federal Office of Energy and provide a different way to protect wind turbines.
All aspects of the surrounding environment can affect the reliability of a turbine’s performance. The Swiss study underscores the significance of understanding these conditions before expanding renewable energy into difficult terrain. Even such a seemingly mundane factor as rainfall can have an effect on turbine performance.
The implications go beyond one Swiss research site and have an impact on future innovations.
Bronwyn has over 20 years of experience in media, digital publishing, and storytelling as a journalist, content creator, and publishing editor. She writes about various niches and has a keen interest in science, technology, energy, and innovation.